Before the premiere of Big Mistakes, expectations were high for Dan Levy, the creator of the acclaimed series Schitt’s Creek. The latter had achieved remarkable success, winning all seven major comedy Emmys in its final season, and fans were eager to see what Levy would do next. However, the tragic passing of Catherine O’Hara in January 2026 halted any potential sequel plans for Schitt’s Creek, leaving a gap that many wondered how Levy would fill.
On April 9, 2026, Levy unveiled Big Mistakes, an eight-episode crime comedy series that quickly made its mark. Debuting at #2 on Netflix’s Top 10 list, the show features a cast that includes Levy himself, alongside Rachel Sennott, Taylor Ortega, and Laurie Metcalf. The plot revolves around two siblings, Nicky and Morgan Dardano, who find themselves entangled in the chaotic world of organized crime. This shift from the heartfelt comedy of Schitt’s Creek to a more chaotic narrative reflects Levy’s versatility as a creator.
Critically, Big Mistakes has been well-received, boasting a Rotten Tomatoes score of 95% based on 19 reviews. The audience score, while slightly lower at 78%, still indicates a positive reception. Critics have noted the show’s ability to blend humor with tension, as highlighted by a review from Vulture: “Even when it’s not being sweet, or when Nicky and Morgan are sincerely terrified about what’s happening to them, the trappings around them are so heightened and silly that Big Mistakes can’t help but come across as mostly a fun time.” This suggests that while the show may tread into darker themes, it maintains a light-hearted essence that resonates with viewers.
Levy’s excitement about the new project is palpable, as he stated, “I’m so excited to be bringing this truly chaotic family story to life with Netflix.” This enthusiasm reflects his commitment to exploring new narratives while still capturing the essence of family dynamics that made Schitt’s Creek a beloved series. The transition from a small-town setting to the underbelly of organized crime illustrates a significant tonal shift, yet it retains the comedic elements that Levy is known for.
Expert voices in the industry have pointed out that the success of Big Mistakes could redefine Levy’s career trajectory. The show’s unique premise and strong critical reception may pave the way for more innovative storytelling in the comedy genre. CBR noted, “There’s something inherently funny about chaos erupting around two people who are too busy arguing about something trivial to notice the bigger picture,” further emphasizing the show’s comedic approach amidst serious themes.
As Levy navigates this new chapter, the impact of Schitt’s Creek looms large. The series set a high bar for comedy, and while Big Mistakes diverges from its predecessor, it also carries the weight of Levy’s previous success. The audience’s mixed but generally favorable reception indicates that while fans may miss the familiar charm of Schitt’s Creek, they are willing to embrace Levy’s new direction.
In summary, Big Mistakes marks a significant evolution for Dan Levy as a creator, showcasing his ability to pivot from the heartfelt narratives of Schitt’s Creek to a more chaotic and comedic exploration of family dynamics within a crime context. As the series continues to unfold, it will be interesting to see how it shapes Levy’s legacy in the television landscape.
